Gas One Refill Adapter vs Flame King Refillable Cylinder: Refill Disposable or Buy Rated?
The Gas One refill hose ($14.99) refills the disposable green bottles you already own — cheapest entry, but refilling DOT-39 single-use cylinders is a grey area and reused bottles eventually vent. The Flame King kit ($59.99) is a cylinder stamped and rated for repeated filling: the pick once you refill often or haul filled cylinders in a vehicle.
Both routes put refillable propane in your 1-lb ecosystem, but only one is unambiguously legal. The Gas One adapter with 4-ft hose ($14.99, 4.5 stars over 344 ratings) refills the ordinary disposable green cylinders most people already own — cheap entry, but refilling single-use cylinders sits in a regulatory grey area and reused disposable bottles eventually vent or warp. The Flame King refillable 1-lb cylinder with kit ($59.99, 4.6 stars over 2,967 ratings) is a DOT-compliant cylinder actually stamped and rated for repeated filling, with the refill valve and adapter in the box — roughly four times the price, and the answer if you refill often or transport filled cylinders in a vehicle.
Choose the Gas One Refill Hose Adapter if
You refill a few times a season, already own green bottles, and want the cheapest working setup — just weigh every fill and inspect each reused bottle before it goes back in service.
$14.99 · 4.5★ · 344 ratings
See the Gas One Refill Hose Adapter →Choose the Flame King Refillable Cylinder if
You refill constantly, haul cylinders in the car, or simply want the route with zero legality questions — a rated cylinder you can keep filling for years.
$59.99 · 4.6★ · 2,967 ratings
See the Flame King Refillable Cylinder →Gas One Refill Hose Adapter vs Flame King Refillable Cylinder: side by side
| Spec | Gas One Refill Hose Adapter | Flame King Refillable Cylinder |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $14.99 | $59.99 |
| Rating | 4.5★ from 344 ratings | 4.6★ from 2,967 ratings |
| Category | Camp Stoves | Camp Stoves |
| Best for | Anyone refilling 1-lb bottles from a 20-lb tank more than occasionally: the 4-foot hose reaches the tank sitting upright on the ground while the bottle sits on a scale, which is the only safe way to fill by weight. | Best for refilling your own 1 lb cylinders from a 20 lb tank, DOT-compliant and cheaper per fill |
| One thing it does well | Solid brass body with precise QCC1/Type 1 threads — seals without PTFE tape | DOT-compliant and stamped for repeated refills — legal to refill and transport in a vehicle |
| One thing to know | Only works when the donor 20-lb tank is warmer than the small cylinder — cold tanks need a warm day or a water bath | Higher upfront cost than a single disposable bottle |
| Who should buy it | Campers converting single-tank setups to a bulk 20 lb supply; Anyone feeding a heater or stove all weekend without canister swaps | Campers tired of $8 disposable canisters who want $1 refills; Anyone who already owns a 20 lb tank and camps more than 6 weekends a year |
Pros and cons, side by side
Gas One Refill Hose Adapter
Pros
- Solid brass body with precise QCC1/Type 1 threads — seals without PTFE tape
- Includes a 4-ft hose so the small canister can sit on a scale while filling
- Hand-tighten only — no wrenches needed at camp
- Fits the standard 20-lb BBQ tank most families already own
Cons
- Only works when the donor 20-lb tank is warmer than the small cylinder — cold tanks need a warm day or a water bath
- You must weigh the bottle or watch the vent closely; overfilling is easy if you rush
- Not for use with disposable-only canisters that are already past their service date
Flame King Refillable Cylinder
Pros
- DOT-compliant and stamped for repeated refills — legal to refill and transport in a vehicle
- CGA600 connection works with any appliance that takes standard 1-lb canisters
- Refill kit included, so it works from day one with a 20-lb donor tank
- Keeps single-use steel bottles out of the landfill every trip
Cons
- Higher upfront cost than a single disposable bottle
- Still needs a 20-lb donor tank to fill from
- You must weigh the cylinder to respect the 80% fill limit; overflowing a refillable tank is still a hazard
What the numbers say
The Gas One Refill Hose Adapter lists at $14.99 and the Flame King Refillable Cylinder at $59.99 — Gas One Refill Hose Adapter is the cheaper of the two by $45.00. The Flame King Refillable Cylinder carries the larger review base (2,967 ratings at 4.6★ vs 344 at 4.5★), which usually means the failure modes are better documented. Price and ratings are read from the TrailMapz catalog and refreshed on every deploy — check the product pages for today's numbers before you buy.
The verdict
Neither product wins outright — the trip decides. Pick the Gas One Refill Hose Adapter if this is your trip: You refill a few times a season, already own green bottles, and want the cheapest working setup — just weigh every fill and inspect each reused bottle before it goes back in service. Pick the Flame King Refillable Cylinder instead if this is your trip: You refill constantly, haul cylinders in the car, or simply want the route with zero legality questions — a rated cylinder you can keep filling for years. Read the two lists against the trip you are actually taking, not the one in the marketing photos, and the decision usually makes itself.
Shopping the whole category? best camp stoves guide put every pick in the category in context, and the side-by-side compare tool lets you put any two products in the catalog next to each other.
More head-to-head comparisons
📖 Keep Reading: Camp Stoves Guides
Field-tested buying advice, comparisons, and setup tips from our guides — useful before you commit.
- Camp Stove Fuel 2026
Propane vs butane vs isobutane camp stove fuel — which canister works in cold weather, what fits your stove, and what each one costs before you buy (2
- Camp Stove Fuel Canisters
Can you recycle or refill a camp stove fuel canister? What's legal, what's safe, and where to take empty 1 lb propane cylinders — checked size by size
- Single-Burner vs 2-Burner Camp Stove
Single-burner vs 2-burner camp stove: boil times, simmer control, fuel costs and weight compared, plus which stove suits your trip type in 2026.
- Isobutane vs Propane Camp Stove
Isobutane vs propane for camp stoves: boiling point, cold-weather cutoff, cost per boil, canister sizes, jetboil fit, which fuel suits your trip.